Tier 2 Criteria

Line graph measuring Tier 2 items by Poor, Average, and Excellent.
Legend:
1. All PeopleSoft
2. All Oracle
3. PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Ariba SC
4. PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, PeopleSoft SC
5. PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Oracle SC

G. Cost (pre-best and final)
PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, PeopleSoft SC - half way between Poor and Average
All Oracle and PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Oracle SC - Average
All PeopleSoft and PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Ariba SC - Excellent
(Evaluation Summary: Summary Results Notes - Based on a 5 year projection)

H. Interface Development
PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, PeopleSoft SC - Poor
PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Ariba SC and All PeopleSoft - Average
All Oracle and PeopleSoft HR, Oracle AF, Oracle SC - Excellent
(Evaluation Summary: Summary Results Notes - Atlas more difficult with PS)

I. Reference Checks
All - Excellent
(Evaluation Summary: Summary Results Notes - Both Vendors had comparable reference checks)

J. Confidence in Vendor Relationship
All - Excellent
(Evaluation Summary: Summary Results Notes - Nextel's confidence in our ability to develop a suitable Vendor Relationship is comparable)

Return to document