|
US Attorneys >
USAM >
Title 9 prev | next | Criminal Resource Manual |
9-2.000
AUTHORITY OF THE UNITED
STATES ATTORNEY IN
CRIMINAL DIVISION MATTERS/PRIOR APPROVALS
9-2.001 Introduction
9-2.010 Investigations
9-2.020 Declining Prosecution
9-2.021 Armed Forces Enlistment as an Alternative
to Federal Prosecution
9-2.022 Pretrial Diversion as an Alternative to
Federal Prosecution
9-2.030 Authorizing Prosecution
9-2.031 Dual and Successive Prosecution Policy
("Petite Policy")
9-2.032 Notification to the Criminal
Division of Certain Prosecutions of Attorneys
9-2.040 Dismissal of Complaints
9-2.041 Cancellation of Unexecuted Arrest
Warrants
9-2.050 Dismissal of Indictments and Informations
9-2.060 Appeals, Mandamus, Stays, Rehearing,
Certiorari
9-2.100 Limitations on United States Attorneys
9-2.101 American Bar Association Standards for
Criminal Justice
9-2.110 Statutory Limitations -- Generally
9-2.111 Statutory Limitations -- Declinations
9-2.112 Statutory Limitations -- Prosecutions
9-2.120 Policy Limitations -- Generally
9-2.131 Matters Assumed by Criminal Division or
Higher Authority
9-2.136 Notification, Consultation, and Approval Requirements for
lnternational Terrorism Matters
9-2.137 Notification Requirements in Domestic
Terrorism Matters
9-2.138 Notification, Consultation, and Approval
Requirements for Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD)
Matters
9-2.139 Notification, Consultation, and Approval
Requirements for Torture, War Crimes, and Genocide Matters
9-2.145 Dismissals
9-2.154 Legislative Proposals by United States
Attorneys
9-2.155 Sensitive Matters
9-2.159 Refusal of Government Departments and
Agencies to Produce Evidence
9-2.170 Decision to Appeal and to File Petitions
in Appellate Courts
9-2.173 Arrest of Foreign Nationals
9-2.180 Strike Forces
9-2.181 Organized Crime Strike Force Unit Duties
9-2.182 Organized Crime Strike Force Unit
Strategic Plans
9-2.183 Organized Crime Strike Force Unit
Personnel
9-2.200 Release of Information -- Press
Information and Privacy
9-2.400 Prior Approvals Chart
(i) the charges are based, in whole or in part, on actions or omissions by the attorney during the representation of a current or former client; and(ii) the attorney's current or former client is, or is likely to be, a witness against the attorney; and
(iii) the client will, or is likely to, testify against the attorney pursuant to a nonprose-cution, cooperation, or similar agreement with the government.
9-2.137 Notification Requirements in Domestic
Terrorism Matters
Initiation.
Grand Jury Subpoenas and Pen/Trap Orders. Where a USAO is aware that another USAO or CTS has opened a related matter, the USAO shall not issue a grand jury subpoena or apply for a pen register or trap and trace order that may affect the related matter without first consulting with CTS and the other district.
Significant Developments and Case Preparation. The USAO shall notify CTS of any significant development in the investigation and prosecution of the matter, including the filing of a search warrant; the filing of a material witness warrant; the application for electronic surveillance; the declination of the matter without filing of charges; the filing and dismissal of criminal or immigration charges; the entering of a plea agreement; the initiation and results of trials; and the results of sentencings and appeals. (As discussed in subsection E below, some of these same court actions also require prior approval of the Assistant Attorney General of the National Security Division.) The USAO is also encouraged to consult with CTS on issues such as investigative tactics and strategies, discovery, jury instructions, sentencing issues, the use of expert witnesses, and the use of cooperating witnesses and cooperating defendants from other jurisdictions.
Information Sharing with the USAO. When CTS becomes aware of information from any source that may be relevant to a WMD matter pending in a USAO, including relevant investigative action that may be planned in another district, CTS shall share that information with the USAO as soon as practicable, to the extent authorized by the originator of the information. Where relevant information known to CTS cannot be shared with a USAO due to originator requirements, CTS shall request that the originator authorize such sharing.
The USAO must seek the prior concurrence of the AAG before entering into a plea agreement in a WMD matter. If the AAG does not concur to the entry of the plea agreement, the disagreement shall be resolved by the Deputy Attorney General.
If exigent circumstances require a USAO to take immediate action in a WMD matter without complying with the notification, consultation, concurrence, or prior approval requirements set forth above, the USAO must promptly notify CTS of any action taken and of the exigent circumstances that precluded obtaining prior approval. The USAO shall also provide CTS copies of any court filings made. If the AAG determines that further review or action appears appropriate, the AAG and the USAO will confer on how best to proceed. Any disagreements will be resolved by the Deputy Attorney General.
Initiation. When the USAO opens any torture, war crimes, or genocide matter, the USAO shall promptly notify the Domestic Security Section (DSS) of the Criminal Division. The notification should include the names and identifiers, if known, of the subjects of the investigation and a general overview of the investigation. Whenever feasible, notification should be made in advance of any action by the USAO, and otherwise as soon as possible, but the USAO should not delay in taking any necessary investigative action, particularly where such action is undercover. Notification may be made by email or telephone (or by secured means where necessary), and may utilize the standard Case Notification Form available from DSS if preferred. If after notification, DSS determines that there are related matters pending in another district that could be affected by the new matter, DSS will so inform the USAO and will advise the other district of the new matter.
Grand Jury Subpoenas and Pen/Trap Orders.
Significant Developments and Case Preparation. The USAO shall notify DSS of any significant development in the investigation and prosecution of the matter, including the filing of a search warrant; the filing of a material witness warrant; the application for electronic surveillance; the declination of the matter without filing of charges; the filing and dismissal of criminal or immigration charges; the entering of a plea agreement; the initiation and results of trials; and the results of sentencings and appeals. (As discussed in subsection E below, some of these same court actions also require prior approval of the Assistant Attorney General of the Criminal Division.) The USAO is also encouraged to consult with DSS on issues such as investigative tactics and strategies, discovery, jury instructions, sentencing issues, the use of expert witnesses, and the use of cooperating witnesses and cooperating defendants from other jurisdictions.
Information Sharing with the USAO. When DSS becomes aware of information from any source that may be relevant to a torture, war crimes, or genocide matter pending in a USAO, including relevant investigative action that may be planned in another district, DSS shall share that information with the USAO as soon as practicable, to the extent authorized by the originator of the information. Where relevant information known to DSS cannot be shared with a USAO due to originator requirements, DSS shall request that the originator authorize such sharing.
USAOs must report the following categories of adverse sentencing decisions to the Appellate Section of the Criminal Division or other appropriate division as soon as possible, but in no event later than 14 days of judgment. This requirement only applies to adverse decisions, i.e., decisions made over the objection of the Government. The categories of adverse decisions required to be reported are as follows:
| By mail: | By overnight courier: |
| Appellate Section Criminal Division P.O. Box 899 Ben Franklin Station Washington, D.C. 20044 |
Appellate Section Criminal Division Room 2266, Main Justice Bldg. 10th St. & Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. Washington, D.C. 20530 |
| USAM SECTION | TYPE & SCOPE OF REPORTING, CONSULTING OR APPROVAL | CONTACT |
| 9-2.031 | Approval is required to continue and/or initiate a federal prosecution affected by Petite policy (dual and successive prosecution). | Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division, through the Witness Immunity Unit of the Office of Enforcement Operations. |
| 9-2.032 | Notification to Criminal Division of certain prosecutions of attorneys, see 9-2.032. | AAG/Criminal Division through Witness Immunity Unit, Office of Enforcement Operations. |
| 9-2.136(D) | The USAO shall notify CTS of the opening of any international terrorism matter. The notification should include the names and identifiers, if known, of subjects of the investigation and a general overview of the investigation, so that CTS may attempt to identify linkages to, and deconflict the investigation with, investigations that may be ongoing in other districts or within CTS and may raise any concerns about the proposed investigation. To allow this process, notification should be made in advance where practicable and otherwise as soon as possible, but the USAO should not delay in taking necessary investigative action, particularly where such action is covert. Notification may be made by email or telephone; or, as necessary to protect classified and sensitive information, by secure fax or telephone; and may utilize the standard Case Notification Form available from CTS if preferred. If after notification, CTS determines that there are related matters pending in other districts that could be affected by investigative action in the new matter, CTS will so inform the USAO and will advise the other districts of the new matter. | Regional ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section. |
| 9-2.136(D) | In all international terrorism matters, the USAO shall notify CTS of significant developments in the investigation and prosecution, including the filing of search warrants; the filing of material witness warrants; the application for electronic surveillance; the declination of the matter without filing of charges; the filing and dismissal of criminal or immigration charges; the entering of plea agreements; the initiation and results of trials; and the results of sentencings and appeals. CTS will be responsible for reporting to the Department's leadership on such developments, although the USAO should also send Urgent Reports on such matters as required by USAM § 3-18.200. Regional ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section. | |
| 9-2.136(E) | Where a USAO is aware that another USAO or CTS has a related international terrorism matter opened, the USAO shall not issue grand jury subpoenas or apply for a pen register or trap and trace order that may impact such related matters without first consulting with CTS and the other district. | Regional ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section, and the ATAC Coordinator or other designated AUSAs in the other district. |
| 9-2.136(F) | When CTS becomes aware of information that may be relevant to an international terrorism matter pending in a USAO, including relevant investigative action that may be planned in another district and issues regarding FISA searches or electronic surveillance, CTS shall share that information directly with the USAO as soon as practicable and to the extent authorized by the originator of the information. Where relevant information is known to CTS but cannot be shared with a USAO due to originator requirements, CTS shall request that the originator authorize such sharing. | The ATAC Coordinator or other designated AUSAs in the other district. |
| 9-2.136(H) | Prior express approval of the Assistant Attorney General of the National
Security Division (AAG) or his designee is presumptively required for
certain court actions involving the international terrorism-focused
(Category 1) statutes:
Prior approval is required in other (Category 2) international terrorism matters only upon AAG request. As noted above, even court actions that do not require prior approval will qualify as significant developments with notification requirements. | AAG of the National Security Division or his/her designee. |
| 9-2.136(H) | Before entering into a plea agreement in a case in which court documents utilize one of the Category 1 statutes (or cases using Category 2 statutes in which the AAG makes a request), the USAO shall notify and seek the concurrence of the AAG, with any disagreement to be resolved by the Deputy Attorney General. | AAG of the National Security Division. |
| 9-2.136(I) | If exigent circumstances require a USAO to take immediate action in an international terrorism matter without complying with the consultation or prior approval requirements set forth above, the USAO must notify CTS of any action taken as soon as practicable thereafter and the exigent circumstances that precluded obtaining prior approval. The USAO shall provide copies of any court filings made. | Regional ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section. |
| 9-2.136(J) | The written certification of the Attorney General is required to allege a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2332. | Regional ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section. |
| 9-2.137 | The USAO shall notify CTS, through its CTS Regional Coordinator, the CTS Domestic Terrorism Coordinator, or the National ATAC Coordinator, of the initiation and significant developments in domestic terrorism investigations (i.e., a terrorism investigation that does not involve foreign nationals, foreign locations, or connections to foreign countries or groups). | Regional ATAC Coordinator, the CTS Domestic Terrorism Coordinator, or the National ATAC Coordinator in the Counterterrorism Section. |
| 9-2.137 | When CTS becomes aware of information that may be relevant to a domestic terrorism matter pending in a USAO, including relevant investigative action that may be planned in another district, CTS shall share that information directly with the USAO as soon as practicable and to the extent authorized by the originator of the information. Where relevant information is known to CTS but cannot be shared with a USAO due to originator requirements, CTS shall request that the originator authorize such sharing. | The ATAC Coordinator or other designated AUSAs in the other district. |
| 9-2.138(C) | Notifying CTS of routine hoax or threat matters is not required, but is encouraged. | Counterterrorism Section |
| 9-2.138(D) | USAOs must promptly notify CTS when the USAO opens any WMD matter. | Counterterrorism Section |
| 9-2.138(D) | Where a USAO is aware that another USAO or CTS has opened a related matter, the USAO shall not issue a grand jury subpoena or apply for a pen register or trap and trace order that may affect the related matter without first consulting with CTS and the other district. | Counterterrorism Section and the other district |
| 9-2.138(D) | The USAO shall notify CTS of any significant development in the investigation and prosecution of the matter, including the filing of a search warrant; the filing of a material witness warrant; the application for electronic surveillance; the declination of the matter without filing of charges; the filing and dismissal of criminal or immigration charges; the entering of a plea agreement; the initiation and results of trials; and the results of sentencings and appeals. | Counterterrorism Section |
| 9-2.138(E) | Prior, express approval of the Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the National Security Division (or his or her designee) is required for the following court actions involving a WMD matter: filing an application for a search warrant; filing an application for a material witness warrant; filing a criminal complaint or information or seeking the return of an indictment; filing a superseding complaint or information, or seeking the return of a superseding indictment; dismissing a charge for which AAG approval was initially required, including as part of a plea agreement; and other specific court filings as requested by the AAG. | Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the National Security Division, through the Counterterrorism Section |
| 9-2.138(F) | The USAO must seek the prior concurrence of the AAG before entering into a plea agreement in a WMD matter. | Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the National Security Division |
| 9-2.138(G) | If exigent circumstances require a USAO to take immediate action in a WMD matter without complying with the notification, consultation, concurrence, or prior approval requirements set forth above, the USAO must promptly notify CTS of any action taken and of the exigent circumstances that precluded obtaining prior approval. | Counterterrorism Section |
| 9-2.139(C) | When the USAO opens any torture, war crimes, or genocide matter, the USAO shall promptly notify the Domestic Security Section (DSS) of the Criminal Division. | Domestic Security Section. |
| 9-2.139(C) | DSS shall immediately notify CTS of all notifications made by a USAO under 9-2.139(C) | Counterterrorism Section. |
| 9-2.139(D) | Where a USAO is aware that another USAO or DSS has opened a related matter, the USAO shall not issue a grand jury subpoena or apply for a pen register or trap and trace order that may affect the related matter without first consulting with DSS and the other district. | Domestic Security Section and the other district. |
| 9-2.139(D) | The USAO shall notify DSS of any significant development in the investigation and prosecution of the matter, including the filing of a search warrant; the filing of a material witness warrant; the application for electronic surveillance; the declination of the matter without filing of charges; the filing and dismissal of criminal or immigration charges; the entering of a plea agreement; the initiation and results of trials; and the results of sentencings and appeals. | Domestic Security Section. |
| 9-2.139(E) | Prior, express approval of the Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the Criminal Division (or his or her designee) is required for the following court actions involving a torture, war crimes, or genocide matter: filing an application for a search warrant; filing an application for a material witness warrant; filing a criminal complaint or information or seeking the return of an indictment; filing a superseding complaint or information, or seeking the return of a superseding indictment; dismissing a charge for which AAG approval was initially required, including as part of a plea agreement; and other specific court filings as requested by the AAG. | Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the Criminal Division, through the Domestic Security Section. |
| 9-2.139(F) | The USAO must seek the prior concurrence of the AAG before entering into a plea agreement in a torture, war crimes, or genocide matter. | Assistant Attorney General (AAG) of the Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.139(G) | If exigent circumstances require a USAO to take immediate action in a torture, war crimes, or genocide matter without complying with the notification, consultation, concurrence, or prior approval requirements set forth above, the USAO must promptly notify DSS of any action taken and of the exigent circumstances that precluded obtaining prior approval. | Domestic Security Section. |
| 9-2.145 | Approval to dismiss any charge or reduce any charge for which approval was necessary to through the Section indict or file an information or complaint. | Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division having jurisdiction of the Offense. |
| 9-2.154 | Legislative proposals should be forwarded for consultation. | Office of Policy and Legislation. |
| 9-2.159 | Approval to dismiss case based on agency refusal to produce documents. | Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.170 | Prior approval is required of the following appeals, requests, or petitions: 1) Any appeal of a decision adverse to the government, including an appeal of an order releasing a charged or convicted defendant or a request to seek a stay of a decision adverse to the government. 2) A petition for rehearing that suggests rehearing en banc--and any rare appeal in which the government wishes to suggest that it be heard initially en banc. See Fed. R. App. P. 35(c). Although a petition for panel rehearing does not require the approval of the Solicitor General, one should not be filed until the Solicitor General has been given the opportunity to decide whether the case merits en banc review. 3) A petition for mandamus or other extraordinary relief. 4) In a government appeal, a request that the case be assigned to a different district court judge on remand. 5) A request for recusal of a court of appeals judge. 6) A petition for certiorari (only the Solicitor General may file petitions for certiorari). | Solicitor General, through Appellate Section, Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.170 | Notification is required of all adverse, appealable district court decisions (including adverse 28 U.S.C.§ 2255 habeas rulings, coram nobis rulings, and forfeiture rulings). USAOs need only report adverse district court Sentencing Guidelines decisions if they wish to obtain authorization to appeal that decision. Other adverse sentencing decisions should be reported. | Appellate Section, Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.170 | Notification is required of every published court of appeals' decision that is adverse to the government in any respect. | Appellate Section, Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.170 | Consultation is required before confessing error in a court of appeals, or before taking a position that may be inconsistent with the government's position in another case. | Appellate Section, Criminal Division. |
| 9-2.173 | Under some treaties, prosecutors are required to notify the consular official when a foreign national is arrested in the United States on federal criminal charges. | Consular Officials of foreign countries. Contact the Office of International Affairs, Criminal Division, to determine whether a treaty requires contact with a consular official. |
| 9-2.181 | Approval is required for Organized Crime Strike Force matters. Every significant action in the investigation and prosecution, from case initiation, court authorized electronic surveillance, witness immunities, witness protection requests, undercover proposals, case indictment, disposition by plea, and other important events must be approved in advance by Organized Crime and Racketeering Section. All significant dispositions, including indictments and verdicts, must be reported to Organized Crime and Racketeering Section in writing. | Organized Crime and Racketeering Section, Criminal Division. |
| USAM SECTION | TYPE & SCOPE OF REPORTING, CONSULTING OR APPROVAL | CONTACT |
| 9-5.150 | Approval is required to move for or consent to closure of judicial proceedings. 28 C.F.R. § 50.9. | Deputy Attorney General (through the Division having supervisory authority over the offense charged; the Office of Enforcement Operations, through the Policy and Statutory Enforcement Unit, handles these approvals for the Criminal Division). |
| 9-7.110 | Approval is required for applications for court orders authorizing the interception of oral, wire or electronic communications (except for applications involving electronic communications to digital-display paging device-which may be approved by a United States Attorney). Approval is also required for extension requests. | Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division or Deputy Assistant Attorney General, through the Office of Enforcement Operations. |
| 9-7.111 | Approval is required for roving interception of wire and oral communications. | Attorney General, Deputy Attorney General, Associate Attorney General, Assistant Attorney General, or Acting Assistant Attorney General, through Office of Enforcement Operations, Criminal Division. |
| 9-7.112 | Approval is required for emergency interceptions under 18 U.S.C. § 2518(7) without a court order. | Attorney General, Deputy Attorney General, Associate Attorney General (after obtaining oral approval of AAG or DAAG of Criminal Division, through Office of Enforcement Operations). |
| 9-7.200 | Approval is required to use video surveillance for law enforcement purposes when there is a constitutionally protected expectation of privacy requiring judicial authorization. | Assistant Attorney General, Deputy Assistant Attorney General, Director and Associate Directors of the Office of Enforcement Operations, Criminal Division. |
| 9-7.302 | Approval is required to intercept a non-telephonic verbal communication without the consent of all parties to the communication (but with the consent of at least one party to the communication),when it is known that: 1) The monitoring relates to an investigation of a member of Congress, a federal judge, a member of the Executive Branch at Executive Level IV, or above, or a person who has served in such capacity within the previous two years; (2) The monitoring relates to an investigation of the Governor, Lieutenant Governor, or Attorney General of any State or Territory, or a judge or justice of the highest court of any State or Territory, and the offense investigated is one involving bribery, conflict of interest, or extortion relating to the performance of his or her official duties (3) Any party to the communication is a member of the diplomatic corps of a foreign country; (4) any party to the communication is or has been a member of the Witness Security Program and that fact is known to the agency involved or its officers; (5) the consenting or nonconsenting person is in the custody of the Bureau of Prisons or the United States Marshals Service; or (6) the Attorney General, Deputy Attorney General, Associate Attorney General, any Assistant Attorney General, or the United States Attorney in the district where an investigation is being conducted has requested the investigating agency to obtain prior written consent before conducting consensual monitoring in a specific investigation. | Director or Associate Director of the Office of Enforcement Operations, Criminal Division. |
| 9-7.500 | The use of pen registers to collect all or part of a URL is prohibited without prior consultation with CCIPS. This policy does not apply to applications for pen register orders that would merely authorize collection of Internet Protocol (IP) addresses, even if such IP addresses can be readily translated into URLs or portions of URLs. Similarly, this policy does not apply to the collection, at a web server, of tracing information indicating the source of requests to view a particular URL using a trap and trace order. | Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section, Criminal Division. |
| 9-8.130 | Notification must be provided prior to filing any motion to transfer a juvenile proceeding to an adult prosecution. | Domestic Security Section, Criminal Division. |
| USAM SECTION | TYPE & SCOPE OF REPORTING, CONSULTING OR APPROVAL | CONTACT |
| 9-10.020 | A district indicting a Title 21 capital offense that occurred before March 6, 2006, should consult with the Capital Case Unit of the Criminal Division regarding indictment and procedure. | Capital Case Unit, Criminal Division. |
| 9-10.040 | In all cases subject to the provisions of USAM Chapter 9-10.000, the Attorney General will make the final decision about whether to seek the death penalty. The Attorney General will convey the final decision to the United States Attorney in a letter authorizing him or her to seek or not to seek the death penalty. | Attorney General. |
| 9-10.040 | In no event may the information identified in the second paragraph of USAM 9-10.040 be disclosed outside the Department and its investigative agencies without prior approval of the Attorney General. The United States Attorneys may exercise their discretion, however, to place additional limits on the scope of |